Italian Love Cake is a recipe I found on Pinterest and fell in love. This cake is simple to make and is a real crowd-pleaser. That is if you can make it past your own front door with the cake in hand.
My husband LOVES this cake and it’s not easy to ask him to share.
I don’t know why it’s called Italian Love Cake but we will just go with it…ok?
Try our Strawberry Shortcake!
Italian Love Cake
This cake switches layers while it bakes. What’s also great is it’s way better after it sets for several hours, overnight is best.
So make it for a family gathering.
Preheat your oven to 350 degrees F and spray a 9×13 inch baking pan with nonstick spray.
In a large bowl, with a handheld mixer, mix together your cake mix according to the directions on the box. Set aside.
In another bowl, using the hand mixer, beat together the ricotta cheese, eggs, sugar, and vanilla until smooth.
Pour the cake batter into the prepared baking dish. Spread to fill the pan evenly.
Once the cake batter is in place, carefully pour the cheese mixture evenly over the top of the cake batter. Spread to cover the cake batter as best as you can.
It switches layers as it bakes.
Bake the cake at 350 F for 1 hour. Remove from the oven and allow to cool completely before frosting.
Check out our Dark Chocolate Espresso Cake.
Allow the cake to cool completely, this part takes a long while.
Once the cake is cool, stir the pudding mix and milk together with a whisk until combined. Carefully, fold the Cool Whip into the pudding until combined.
Spread the pudding mixture over the top of the cooled cake. Cover the cake and refrigerate at least 6 hours before serving. I let it refrigerate overnight, it tastes even better the next day.
Everyone will love this moist, light and delicious cake. I’m thinking I might try a different flavor cake mix next time. I’ll let you know how that works out.
Try our Best Homemade Carrot Cake recipe!
Italian Love Cake
Ingredients
- 1 package chocolate cake mix and the ingredients needed to make the cake according to the package
- 2 lbs ricotta cheese
- 4 large eggs
- ¾ cup sugar
- 1 tsp. pure vanilla extract
Whipped Topping:
- 5.1 oz instant chocolate pudding mix (1 – 5.1 oz. package )
- 1 cup cold milk
- 8 oz. Cool Whip
Instructions
- Preheat your oven to 350*F and spray a 9×13 baking pan with nonstick spray.
- In a large bowl, with a hand mixer, mix together your cake mix according to the directions on the box. Set aside.
- In another bowl, using the hand mixer, beat together the ricotta cheese, eggs, sugar, and vanilla until smooth.
- Pour the cake batter into the prepared baking dish. Spread to fill the pan evenly. Once the cake batter is in place, carefully pour the cheese mixture evenly over the top of the cake batter. Spread to cover the cake batter as best as you can.
- Bake the cake at 350F for 1 hour. Remove from the oven and allow to cool completely before frosting.
- Once the cake is cool, stir the pudding mix and milk together with a whisk until combined. Carefully, fold the Cool Whip into the pudding until combined.
- Spread the pudding mixture over the top of the cooled cake.
- Cover the cake and refrigerate at least 6 hours before serving. I let it refrigerate overnight, it tastes even better the next day.
Nutrition
Recipe from chewnibblenosh
Comments
Edie C
December 28, 2015That sounds really delicious!
DSTR
December 28, 2015It is, I hope you try it! Thanks for stopping by, Edie!
Megan
December 28, 2015This looks fantastic! And so easy! I will definitely try for my next party. Thanks for sharing.
http://www.excelathome.net
DSTR
December 28, 2015Thanks, Megan!
Joanne
May 24, 2021I only have one pint of ricotta cheese , can I cut the filling recipe in half?
DSTR
May 24, 2021Never tried it, I wouldn’t recommend it. 🙁
Margaret @ Creative Madness Mama
December 29, 2015It’s gorgeous and looks delicious, but I am so not a ricotta fan. I guess I’ll skip this one.
DSTR
December 30, 2015Margaret, my neighbor also hates ricotta but loves this cake.
Erin @ Stay At Home Yogi
December 30, 2015with a name like that it has to be good! 🙂
Donna A DeAnnuntis
November 23, 2019Just found this recipe. My cake didn’t switch but boy was it delicious!! Thank you so much for this amazing recipe!
Tricia G
February 17, 2020Years ago I was a waitress at a restaurant/party house. A customer made this for the guest of honor.
We were given the recipe the only difference was the recipe had marble cake mix instead of chocolate.
This cake was such a huge hit! People who don’t like. Sweets or especially people who don’t like ricotta, absolutely loved this cake.
I’m gonna make it tonight because I came upon this recipe after all these years and just happen to have all of these ingredients.
I’m so excited to make this.
The one any only problem is that this is a very rich dessert and is very filling.
Be sure to have the recipe on hand, everyone will want a copy.
Carlee
December 30, 2015That looks AMAZING! With all of that ricotta and chocolate it has to be good!
DSTR
December 30, 2015Thanks, Carlee!
Brittney
December 31, 2015Okay, this is going on our Must-Try list!
DSTR
December 31, 2015I hope you enjoy it, Brittney!
Molly
December 31, 2015That looks absolutely delcious
Mollyxxx
DSTR
December 31, 2015Thanks, Molly!
Leslie
January 3, 2016This looks so good, I love Italian desserts. A cannoli is my weakness! I need this in my life.
DSTR
January 4, 2016Oh…cannoli! One of my favs too! Thanks for stopping by, Leslie!
Miz Helen
January 3, 2016I pinned your amazing Italian Love Cake and can’t wait to try it! Thanks so much for sharing with Full Plate Thursday and Happy New Year!
Miz Helen
DSTR
January 4, 2016Thank you Miz Helen!
This Momma's Meandering Mondays 132! - This Momma's Ramblings
January 4, 2016[…] favorite post came from Don’t Sweat the Recipe with the post “Italian Love Cake“! “Oh this looks absolutely amazing! I have a major sweet tooth, and this looks like it […]
DSTR
January 4, 2016Thank you!
Meandering Mondays 132 - Giveaways 4 Mom
January 4, 2016[…] favorite post came from Don’t Sweat the Recipe with the post “Italian Love Cake“! “Oh this looks absolutely amazing! I have a major sweet tooth, and this looks like it […]
Lissette
January 4, 2016This looks so heavenly and like something everyone in my family would love! Thanks for sharing at the Friday Funday Blog Hop! 🙂
The Gathering Spot #185 – Mamal Diane
January 4, 2016[…] This week’s featured Post is from Don’t Sweat the Recipe. They shared Italian Love Cake. […]
Wakey Wakey #102 - iknead2knit
January 5, 2016[…] Eggplant is packed with creamy veggie power to satisfy even this biggest plant-based skeptic! Italian Love Cake Don’t Sweat The Recipe Italian Love Cake is a recipe I found on Pinterest and fell in […]
Tracey M.
January 5, 2016Wow! Looks delicious! We love dessert in this house so we’ll have to give this recipe a try.
Wake Up Wednesday Link Party! | Far From Normal
January 5, 2016[…] Eggplant is packed with creamy veggie power to satisfy even this biggest plant-based skeptic! Italian Love Cake Don’t Sweat The Recipe Italian Love Cake is a recipe I found on Pinterest and fell in […]
The 1st Wake Up Wednesday of 2016! | Epic Mommy Adventures
January 5, 2016[…] Eggplant is packed with creamy veggie power to satisfy even this biggest plant-based skeptic! Italian Love Cake Don’t Sweat The Recipe Italian Love Cake is a recipe I found on Pinterest and […]
Jann Olson
January 5, 2016Chocolate lovers would love this. It’s pretty, but can you believe that I don’t like chocolate cake? White foe me. lol! Thanks for sharing with SYC.
hugs,
Jann
DSTR
January 6, 2016LOL Thanks, Jan!
DSTR
January 6, 2016LOL Thanks, Jann!
Wake Up Wednesday Linky Party #102
January 5, 2016[…] Eggplant is packed with creamy veggie power to satisfy even this biggest plant-based skeptic! Italian Love Cake Don’t Sweat The Recipe Italian Love Cake is a recipe I found on Pinterest and fell in […]
Katie
January 6, 2016This cake looks so pretty with those gorgeous layers – appears to be a hit to me! Pinned and congrats on the feature at Wake up Wednesday! 🙂
DSTR
January 7, 2016Thank you so much, Katie!
Danita Carr
January 6, 2016Oh my! This looks amazing!! Pinning for later 🙂 #SmallVictories
Lisa
January 6, 2016We are definitely going to try this! It looks amazing! Thanks for linking up with “Try a New Recipe Tuesday.” I hope you can join us again this week. https://our4kiddos.blogspot.com/2016/01/try-new-recipe-tuesday-january-5.html
Tanya @ Mom's Small Victories
January 7, 2016This looks fantastic. How cool that the layers switch during baking. Thanks for sharing with Small Victories Sunday Linkup. Pinning to our linkup board and hope you found some great posts to visit this week!
Indigo
October 14, 2019I know I’m 3 years late to reply, but when I poured the ricotta in I thought, “oh no, this doesn’t seem right” and sure enough we got a beautiful surprise when we cut into the cake! Lol! It was perfect!!
Scraptastic Saturday Linky Party 66
January 9, 2016[…] […]
Small Victories Sunday Linkup {84} - Mom's Small VictoriesMom's Small Victories
January 9, 2016[…] Italian Love Cake from Don’t Sweat the Recipe […]
O Taste and See Small Victories Sunday Linkup 1/9/16 - O Taste and See
January 9, 2016[…] Italian Love Cake from Don’t Sweat the Recipe […]
Small Victories Sunday #45 - The Mad Mommy -
January 10, 2016[…] Italian Love Cake from Don’t Sweat the Recipe […]
Leigh Powell Hines
January 10, 2016This looks great. Congrats on being a featured blogger with Small Victories Link Up
DSTR
January 10, 2016Thank you Leigh!
Welcome To Small Victories Sunday! | Keystrokes By Kimberly | Life, Style, Travel & Everything In Between
January 11, 2016[…] Italian Love Cake from Don’t Sweat the Recipe […]
Small Victories Sunday Linkup 1.10.16 | Divas With A Purpose
January 12, 2016[…] Italian Love Cake from Don’t Sweat the Recipe […]
Small Victories Sunday Linkup {84}
January 19, 2016[…] Italian Love Cake from Don’t Sweat the Recipe […]
Taina
February 27, 2016I made this today and wow!! Its yummazing!!!!
DSTR
February 29, 2016I’m so glad you like it! Thank you for stopping by, Taina!
Helen
May 20, 2016Hi. I love the pictures and I just wish I could have a sice of the cake right now. This cake is on my To do list. However, I live in Lagos Nigeria and it is extremely difficult to get ricotta cheese, pudding mix and cool whip. Can I substitute cream cheese or marscarpone for ricotta? Can I use Danica sweet whip( its a sort of non lactose whipping cream made with hydrogenated vegetable fat among other ingredients) in place of cool whip? Can I make the pudding from scratch? I really don’t know where I will get the pudding mix from and I love to make things from scratch. I look forward to response.
DSTR
May 20, 2016I can’t recommend substituting any of the ingredients. Mascarpone is a much creamier and thicker texture than ricotta, I’m not sure that it would cook properly. I have never used a vegetable fat whipping cream so I can’t speak on that part. All I can say is the only way to find out is give it a try. Helen, if you do try all the changes I would love to hear from you on how it turns out. Thank you so much for stopping by and I’m sorry I couldn’t be of more help. 🙂
Meaghan
September 16, 2016You can definitely make different variations of this cake by mixing different cakes and pudding flavors. You can also add some extracts into the ricotta cheese mixture. I have made:
Orange Dreamcicle. Orange cake and vanilla pudding.
Lemon cream. Lemon cake, lemon extract and vanilla pudding
Chocolate-caramel-banana. Chocolate cake, banana flavored filling and Caramel pudding.
The classic recipe is still the best though.
Karen
October 14, 20165.1 pudding or 1.5? I have never seen 5.1. Thanks.
DSTR
October 18, 2016https://www.walmart.com/ip/Jell-O-Instant-Vanilla-Pudding-Pie-Filling-5.1-oz/13812808
Hi Karen, I’m pretty sure it’s just the standard box. I have made this cake several times but don’t remember for sure the ounces in the package.
Karen
October 18, 2016Thanks! I made this cake yesterday using the 1.5 oz. box. It was delicious! What a wonderful recipe. (I also used the 8 oz. size of Cool Whip because I bought the wrong size, but it worked perfectly.)
DSTR
October 18, 2016I happy you like the recipe and worked out for you! 🙂 Thanks for letting me know, Karen!
Debbie
November 27, 2019The first time I made this cake it came out perfectly. The second time the edges burned and the middle didn’t cook at all. I guess I need a new stove.
elizabeth
December 18, 2016What did I do wrong the ricotta layer did not bake to the bottom like the picture showed? The taste of the cake was delicious and I substituted cool whip with real whipping cream and I used only 3 eggs in the cheese mixture. Any suggestions
DSTR
December 19, 2016Elizabeth, I’m not really sure. I’ve made this cake countless times and it always bakes perfectly. Maybe it was using only 3 eggs that caused this to occur. When baking I recommend always following the instructions. Real whipping cream is a perfect idea for the topping and wouldn’t have had any effect on the cake itself.
nalesniki
March 24, 2017It seems delicious!!!
Denise
March 30, 2017I wish Someone would make this for Me! It looks Devine!!!!
ROZ
December 14, 2017MADE THIS CAKE TWICE AND EVERYONE LOVE LOVE LOVES IT…..THANKS FOR THE RECIPE. SAW A CAKE ON QVC AND IT WAS THE LOVE CAKE SELLING FOR 69.00.
DSTR
December 14, 2017Roz, we are so happy to hear from our readers! Thank you so much for coming by to tell us how much you love the cake, it’s one of our favorites too! Merry Christmas!
Maria
April 15, 2018I made this cake twice, following the directions exactly and don’t know why the cake doesn’t switch with the Ricotta. 🙁 It is still good.
Paula Willford
November 12, 2018My mom passed away about 10 years ago and she made this all the time! Thanks for posting it so I could make it for my extended family now!
This is by far my favorite cake!
Mary Biehn
February 11, 2019I have made this a few times. The problem I have is that the bottom always gets soggy. Am I doing something wrong???
DSTR
February 12, 2019Hi, Mary. I’m not quite sure. I have never had a problem with it getting soggy.
Small Victories Sunday Linkup | Tidbits of Experience
April 17, 2019[…] Italian Love Cake from Don’t Sweat the Recipe […]
John
October 2, 2019I made it in a pyrex dish, and the cake baked fine in an hour, but it did not flip with the ricotta mixture. The cake mix was a bit beyond its expiration date, but otherwise everything seemed like I followed all the directions. Still tasted good, but the ricotta filling taste got a little faded between the chocolate cake and the chocolate icing. I still liked, my wife didn’t.
Donna A DeAnnuntis
November 23, 2019Just found this recipe. My cake didn’t switch but boy was it delicious!! Thank you so much for this amazing recipe!
Kaity
June 9, 2020I have been making this cake for years. It is great. I like to substitute flavored seltzer water in the cake mix and today I made a dairy free version using 2 packages of firm tofu instead of the ricotta. I blended in about 2 tbsp of canola oil into the tofu and followed the rest of the recipe. It was a really great alternative.
Kaity
June 9, 2020I also used a brownie mix instead of cake mix. It ends up meting a bit more rich and the layers don’t switch as much. But it’s still great.
Jean Galante
December 23, 2020This is a family favorite in my house.
Chya colbert
January 7, 2021Can you freeze this cake?
DSTR
January 9, 2021We have never had any leftovers to freeze ;). But give it a try and let us know how it works out.
Cheyenne
May 7, 2021I dont know what I did wrong I followed the directions but the ricotta layer sank into the cake layer
DSTR
May 7, 2021Hmmm, we’re not sure either. We have never had this happen.
Sharon Bush
June 22, 2021I completely forgot to put the eggs in my ricotta mixture and it is baking.. will it still taste good?
DSTR
June 23, 2021Hmmmm, I’m not really sure how this will turn out for you.