Smoked Pork and Turkey Brunswick Stew (Savory, Smoky, and Not Sweet)

Brunswick stew is often made sweet, but when it’s built around leftover smoked meat and careful seasoning, it becomes something else entirely. This version is savory, peppery, and deeply smoky, made with smoked pulled pork and smoked turkey, restrained tomato, and no added sugar. It’s meant to taste like real barbecue, not ketchup soup.

Jump to Recipe Print Recipe

Why You Will Love This Recipe

If you’re into barbecue for the smoke, the seasoning, and the way good BBQ actually tastes, this Brunswick stew should feel right at home. It’s built around leftover smoked pork and smoked turkey, so the meat stays front and center, with the vegetables adding body and balance instead of taking over. Nothing gets cloying or heavy, and the smoke is allowed to lead. Click the links there for those recipes.

This version is what we prefer because it tastes like barbecue, not barbecue sauce. The meat doesn’t get lost in sweetness, like so many other recipes (and at BBQ joints).

The ingredients are straightforward, and if you cook barbecue regularly, you probably already have most of what you need.

How To Make A Proper Brunswick Stew

A good Brunswick stew comes together in stages. None of them are complicated, but the order matters. You build the base first, let the vegetables do their job, and bring the smoked meat in at the end so it stays distinct and doesn’t get lost in the pot.

Step 1: Build the base

Start with a heavy pot or Dutch oven over medium heat. Add the oil or bacon fat, then the onion and celery with a pinch of salt. Let them cook until they soften and pick up just a little color, not browned, just relaxed and aromatic.

Once that’s there, add the garlic and tomato paste. Cook it briefly until it smells rich and a little deeper. You’re not making a tomato stew here. This is just about adding some backbone.

Step 2: Add structure

Stir in the diced potatoes, spices, and bay leaf, then toss everything to evenly coat the potatoes. The potatoes are there to give the stew body, not to take over, so keep the dice small and consistent, about a 1/2″ dice.

Pour in the chicken stock and bring it to a gentle simmer. Let it cook uncovered for 6–8 minutes, just until the potatoes are tender but still holding their shape. As they soften, they’ll naturally thicken the stew without making it heavy.

Step 3: Add the vegetables

Once the potatoes are tender, add the drained tomatoes, lima beans, corn, and okra. Stir gently and return the pot to a low, uncovered simmer.

Let the stew cook for 6–8 minutes, stirring occasionally, just until the liquid reduces slightly and the stew thickens. The potatoes should still be visible and intact, with only a little breakdown helping give the stew body.

Step 4: Add the smoked meat

With the stew thickened slightly, gently stir in the smoked pulled pork and smoked turkey. Add the apple cider vinegar and Worcestershire sauce. Keep the heat at a low simmer and go easy with the spoon; you don’t want to over-shred the meat.

Let the stew cook for 10–12 minutes, just long enough for the meat to warm through and the smoke to settle into the stew. The meat is already cooked, so this step is about integration, not cooking it again.

Step 5: Finish and adjust

Pull the bay leaf and give the stew a taste. At this point, everything should be working together, so you’re just fine-tuning. Adjust the salt or black pepper as needed until the stew tastes balanced and complete and to your liking.

The stew should be thick, spoonable, and meat-forward, with smoke and seasoning leading the way. If you prefer a little sweetness or extra tang, this is the moment to add a small amount of BBQ sauce, a tablespoon at a time, until it suits your taste. Keep it restrained. The stew should still taste like barbecue, not sauce.

We have tried Brunswick stew in so many places and have left underwhelmed each time. The variety, even in our local area, is all over the place, but all overly sweet and disappointing. This Brunswick stew recipe is for us.

If you decide to give this a whirl, or have any questions about this recipe, or any other recipe for that matter, join our Discord server and reach out. We’d love to see your pics, and we’re available most of the time.

Tips

• Use leftover BBQ: This stew is designed for smoked meat that’s already cooked. Freshly smoked pork and turkey work, but leftovers are ideal and often have a better texture.
• Keep the simmer gentle: A low, steady simmer is key. Boiling hard will break down the vegetables too much and shred the meat.
• Let the potatoes do the work: The diced Yukon Golds add body naturally. You don’t need flour or thickeners — time and gentle reduction are enough.
• Taste late, not early: The stew changes as it reduces. Hold off on final seasoning until the end so you don’t overdo the salt or pepper.
• Even better the next day: Like most stews, this one tightens up and tastes even better after resting overnight.

Variations

• Different smoked meats: Smoked chicken or leftover brisket work well in place of turkey or pork, as long as they’re not heavily sauced.
• Heat level: Add more cayenne or a pinch of crushed red pepper if you want extra heat. This stew handles spice well. I find that a 1/4 tsp of ceyanne is a perfect amount to add some warmth without being overbearing. My wife says it’s too much. So, use it as you will for you and yours.
• Finish with BBQ sauce (optional): If you like a little sweetness or tang, stir in your favorite BBQ sauce a tablespoon at a time at the end. Keep it restrained so the stew still tastes like barbecue, not sauce. We do NOT do this. It’s perfect the way it is, but I know that people like their bbq sauce. 🙂
• Chunkier or smoother: For a thicker stew, let it reduce for a few extra minutes. For a looser texture, add a splash of stock before serving.

Choosing the Right Consistency (Stock Amount & Thickness)

The amount of stock you use makes a noticeable difference in how this Brunswick stew eats. I tested this recipe with both 4 cups and 6 cups of stock, and while the flavor stayed the same, the texture changed in a meaningful way.

With 4 cups of stock, the stew is very thick and hearty. It is spoon-standing thick, with the meat and vegetables packed tightly together. This version feels especially satisfying as a main dish, particularly with cornbread on the side.

With 6 cups of stock, the stew is still meat-forward and substantial, but a little looser and more ladle-friendly. It’s easier to serve as a side alongside other barbecue, and it holds its texture well without feeling soupy. You can still stand the spoon, but it has more broth and will be looser.

It really comes down to preference. If you like a dense, hearty stew, use less stock. If you prefer something a little more relaxed and spoonable, go with the full amount.

One thing to keep in mind: this stew thickens quickly as it sits. Between the potatoes, beans, and vegetables, it absorbs broth at a noticeable rate — you’ll often see a difference within about an hour. That’s normal and expected with this style of stew.

When reheating, it’s completely fine to add a splash of chicken stock to loosen it back up. Add a little at a time and warm it gently until it reaches the consistency you like. The flavor holds up well, so you’re not watering it down — just bringing it back to life.

FAQs

Other Amazing Leftover BBQ Recipes

Share With Your Friends And Family!